link voor Ben E. King - What Is Soul

link voor Air - All I Need

link voor This Mortal Coil - You And Your Sister

Puntenverdeling: 8-7-6-4-3-2 (dit laten staan!)

Ronde 1 - Ladder 55: thelion deelt geen +4 uit; pm gestuurd

133 Sinéad O'Connor - Troy 7
85 Mercury Rev - The Dark Is Rising 2
84 Novastar - Wrong
82 Peter Gabriel & Kate Bush - Don't Give Up
68 Tindersticks - Bathtime 3
66 Built To Spill - Traces 8
63 Marlena Shaw - California Soul 4
60 Radical Face - Glory
56 Coldplay - Amsterdam
51 The Knife - We Share Our Mother's Health 6
28 Ben E. King - What Is Soul

--------------------------

Ronde 1 - Ladder 56: niet alles van Kate krijgt punten van mij maar uitgerekend deze doet het slecht

119 Muse - New Born 2
104 This Mortal Coil - You And Your Sister
90 The Veils - Under The Folding Branches
90 Air - All I Need
81 The Sound - I Give You Pain 8
80 Procol Harum - Grand Hotel
70 The Beatles - Let It Be 6
65 Can - Half Past One 3
55 Kate Bush - This Woman's Work 7
45 The Breeders - Safari 4
41 Chris Bell - You And Your Sister

Deadline: 17.00 uur

Puntenverdeling: 8-7-6-4-3-2 (dit laten staan!)

Ronde 1 - Ladder 55: thelion deelt geen +4 uit; pm gestuurd

135 Sinéad O'Connor - Troy +2
92 Novastar - Wrong +8
88 Mercury Rev - The Dark Is Rising +3
82 Peter Gabriel & Kate Bush - Don't Give Up
73 Built To Spill - Traces +7
68 Tindersticks - Bathtime
63 Marlena Shaw - California Soul
60 Radical Face - Glory
56 Coldplay - Amsterdam
55 The Knife - We Share Our Mother's Health +4
34 Ben E. King - What Is Soul +6

--------------------------

Ronde 1 - Ladder 56:

127 Muse - New Born +8
104 This Mortal Coil - You And Your Sister
97 Air - All I Need +7
90 The Veils - Under The Folding Branches
87 The Sound - I Give You Pain +6
84 Procol Harum - Grand Hotel +4
70 The Beatles - Let It Be
67 Can - Half Past One +2
55 Kate Bush - This Woman's Work
48 The Breeders - Safari +3
41 Chris Bell - You And Your Sister

Deadline: 17.00 uur

Puntenverdeling: 8-7-6-4-3-2 (dit laten staan!)

Ronde 1 - Ladder 55: thelion deelt geen +4 uit; pm gestuurd

135 Sinéad O'Connor - Troy
92 Novastar - Wrong
88 Mercury Rev - The Dark Is Rising
82 Peter Gabriel & Kate Bush - Don't Give Up
73 Built To Spill - Traces
68 Tindersticks - Bathtime
63 Marlena Shaw - California Soul
60 Radical Face - Glory
56 Coldplay - Amsterdam
55 The Knife - We Share Our Mother's Health
34 Ben E. King - What Is Soul

--------------------------

Ronde 1 - Ladder 56:

134 Muse - New Born 7
107 This Mortal Coil - You And Your Sister 3
99 Air - All I Need 2
94 The Veils - Under The Folding Branches 4
93 The Sound - I Give You Pain 6 (ontdekking)
84 Procol Harum - Grand Hotel
78 The Beatles - Let It Be 8
67 Can - Half Past One
55 Kate Bush - This Woman's Work
48 The Breeders - Safari
41 Chris Bell - You And Your Sister

Deadline: 17.00 uur

Sta echt ervan te kijken dat het veel betere origineel helemaal onderaan staat en de TMC-cover bijna bovenaan

Wat mij betreft is de versie van Chris Bell ook beter. Zal vanmiddag even stemmen..

En Muse op 1?

Terecht, naar mijn mening stelt het origineel veel minder voor als de cover. Ik vind het origineel een beetje zielloos klinken en niet boven het gemiddelde singer-songwriter niveau uitkomen terwijl de cover meer emotie losmaakt bij mij. Misschien dat die vrouwenstem het ook gewoon wel doet, maar TMC viel bij mij daardoor nog net in de punten terwijl Chris Bell daar totaal geen aanspraak op kon maken.

Ach ja, dat TMC beter scoort verbaast nog niet eens zo. Volgens mij scoort hun versie van Song to the Siren ook al jaren beter dan het (eveneens in mijn ogen betere) origineel. Het depressieve 80's-geluid van de band doet het goed bij al die wavers hier... Maar toch, zo'n groot verschil tussen beide versies vind ik wel erg cru...

CB heeft imo een erg irritant piepstemmetje - TMC komt daar wat makkelijker mee weg

Twee matige ladders

Ronde 1 - Ladder 55: thelion deelt geen +4 uit; pm gestuurd

135 Sinéad O'Connor - Troy
92 Novastar - Wrong
92 Mercury Rev - The Dark Is Rising +4
82 Peter Gabriel & Kate Bush - Don't Give Up
76 Built To Spill - Traces +3
75 Tindersticks - Bathtime +7
71 Marlena Shaw - California Soul +8
60 Radical Face - Glory
57 The Knife - We Share Our Mother's Health +2
56 Coldplay - Amsterdam
40 Ben E. King - What Is Soul +6

--------------------------

Ronde 1 - Ladder 56:

134 Muse - New Born
111 This Mortal Coil - You And Your Sister +4
102 Air - All I Need +3
100 The Veils - Under The Folding Branches +6
93 The Sound - I Give You Pain
84 Procol Harum - Grand Hotel
85 The Beatles - Let It Be +7
75 Can - Half Past One +8
57 Kate Bush - This Woman's Work +2
48 The Breeders - Safari
41 Chris Bell - You And Your Sister

Deadline: 17.00 uur

Ronde 1 - Ladder 55: thelion deelt geen +4 uit; pm gestuurd

137 Sinéad O'Connor - Troy +2
98 Mercury Rev - The Dark Is Rising +6
92 Novastar - Wrong
86 Peter Gabriel & Kate Bush - Don't Give Up +4
84 Built To Spill - Traces +8
78 Tindersticks - Bathtime +3
71 Marlena Shaw - California Soul
67 Radical Face - Glory +7
57 The Knife - We Share Our Mother's Health
56 Coldplay - Amsterdam
40 Ben E. King - What Is Soul

--------------------------

Ronde 1 - Ladder 56:

141 Muse - New Born +7
115 This Mortal Coil - You And Your Sister +4
103 The Veils - Under The Folding Branches +3
102 Air - All I Need
101 The Sound - I Give You Pain +8
86 Procol Harum - Grand Hotel +2
85 The Beatles - Let It Be
75 Can - Half Past One
57 Kate Bush - This Woman's Work
48 The Breeders - Safari
47 Chris Bell - You And Your Sister +6

Deadline: 17.00 uur

Ronde 1 - Ladder 55: thelion deelt geen +4 uit; pm gestuurd

145 Sinéad O'Connor - Troy +8
98 Mercury Rev - The Dark Is Rising
94 Novastar - Wrong +2
93 Peter Gabriel & Kate Bush - Don't Give Up +7
84 Tindersticks - Bathtime +6
84 Built To Spill - Traces
74 Marlena Shaw - California Soul +3
67 Radical Face - Glory
61 The Knife - We Share Our Mother's Health +4
56 Coldplay - Amsterdam
40 Ben E. King - What Is Soul

--------------------------

Ronde 1 - Ladder 56:

148 Muse - New Born +7
119 This Mortal Coil - You And Your Sister +4
108 Air - All I Need +6
103 The Veils - Under The Folding Branches
101 The Sound - I Give You Pain
86 Procol Harum - Grand Hotel
85 The Beatles - Let It Be
83 Can - Half Past One +8
60 Kate Bush - This Woman's Work +3
49 Chris Bell - You And Your Sister +2
48 The Breeders - Safari

Deadline: 17.00 uur

Ronde 1 - Ladder 55: thelion deelt geen +4 uit; pm gestuurd

149 Sinéad O'Connor - Troy +4
98 Mercury Rev - The Dark Is Rising
96 Novastar - Wrong +2
93 Peter Gabriel & Kate Bush - Don't Give Up
90 Built To Spill - Traces +6
87 Tindersticks - Bathtime +3
82 Marlena Shaw - California Soul +8
67 Radical Face - Glory
64 Coldplay - Amsterdam +7
61 The Knife - We Share Our Mother's Health
40 Ben E. King - What Is Soul

--------------------------

Ronde 1 - Ladder 56:

148 Muse - New Born
125 This Mortal Coil - You And Your Sister +6
115 Air - All I Need +7
105 The Sound - I Give You Pain +4
103 The Veils - Under The Folding Branches
88 Procol Harum - Grand Hotel +2
88 The Beatles - Let It Be +3
83 Can - Half Past One
60 Kate Bush - This Woman's Work
56 The Breeders - Safari +8
49 Chris Bell - You And Your Sister


Deadline: 17.00 uur

Ronde 1 - Ladder 55: thelion deelt geen +4 uit; pm gestuurd

155 Sinéad O'Connor - Troy 6
103 Novastar - Wrong 7
98 Mercury Rev - The Dark Is Rising
95 Peter Gabriel & Kate Bush - Don't Give Up 2
94 Built To Spill - Traces 4
90 Tindersticks - Bathtime 3
82 Marlena Shaw - California Soul
75 Radical Face - Glory 8
64 Coldplay - Amsterdam
61 The Knife - We Share Our Mother's Health
40 Ben E. King - What Is Soul

--------------------------

Ronde 1 - Ladder 56: zwakke ladder

155 Muse - New Born 7
125 This Mortal Coil - You And Your Sister
115 Air - All I Need
109 The Sound - I Give You Pain 4
109 The Veils - Under The Folding Branches 6
96 The Beatles - Let It Be 8
90 Procol Harum - Grand Hotel 2
83 Can - Half Past One
63 Kate Bush - This Woman's Work 3
56 The Breeders - Safari
49 Chris Bell - You And Your Sister


Deadline: 17.00 uur

Ronde 1 - Ladder 55: thelion deelt geen +4 uit; pm gestuurd

161 Sinéad O'Connor - Troy 6
106 Novastar - Wrong 3
100 Mercury Rev - The Dark Is Rising 2
99 Peter Gabriel & Kate Bush - Don't Give Up 4
94 Built To Spill - Traces
90 Tindersticks - Bathtime
90 Marlena Shaw - California Soul 8
75 Radical Face - Glory
64 Coldplay - Amsterdam
61 The Knife - We Share Our Mother's Health
47 Ben E. King - What Is Soul 7

--------------------------

Ronde 1 - Ladder 56:

155 Muse - New Born
128 This Mortal Coil - You And Your Sister 3
121 Air - All I Need 6
109 The Sound - I Give You Pain
109 The Veils - Under The Folding Branches
103 The Beatles - Let It Be 7
90 Procol Harum - Grand Hotel
87 Can - Half Past One 4
71 Kate Bush - This Woman's Work 8
56 The Breeders - Safari
51 Chris Bell - You And Your Sister 2


Deadline: 17.00 uur

Ronde 1 - Ladder 55:

167 Sinéad O'Connor - Troy 6
108 Novastar - Wrong 2
104 Mercury Rev - The Dark Is Rising 4
102 Peter Gabriel & Kate Bush - Don't Give Up 3
102 Built To Spill - Traces 8
90 Tindersticks - Bathtime
90 Marlena Shaw - California Soul
75 Radical Face - Glory
71 Coldplay - Amsterdam 7
61 The Knife - We Share Our Mother's Health
47 Ben E. King - What Is Soul

--------------------------

Ronde 1 - Ladder 56:

158 Muse - New Born 3
130 This Mortal Coil - You And Your Sister 2
121 Air - All I Need
117 The Sound - I Give You Pain 8
115 The Veils - Under The Folding Branches 6
110 The Beatles - Let It Be 7
94 Procol Harum - Grand Hotel 4
87 Can - Half Past One
71 Kate Bush - This Woman's Work
56 The Breeders - Safari
51 Chris Bell - You And Your Sister


Deadline: 17.00 uur

Ik vind het bij Song To The Siren anders dan bij deze. Van Song To The Siren vind ik het origineel beter, maar van You And Your Sister de cover.

Spoon geeft Coldplay een punt te veel.

Opmerking 'thelion deelt geen +4 uit; pm gestuurd' is verdwenen bij ladder 55

Puntenverdeling: 8-7-6-4-3-2 (dit laten staan!)

Ronde 1 - Ladder 55: thelion deelt geen +4 uit; pm gestuurd

175 Sinéad O'Connor - Troy +8
108 Novastar - Wrong
110 Mercury Rev - The Dark Is Rising +6
109 Peter Gabriel & Kate Bush - Don't Give Up +7
102 Built To Spill - Traces
94 Marlena Shaw - California Soul +4
92 Tindersticks - Bathtime +2
75 Radical Face - Glory
73 Coldplay - Amsterdam -1 (corr spoon) +3
61 The Knife - We Share Our Mother's Health
47 Ben E. King - What Is Soul

--------------------------

Ronde 1 - Ladder 56:

160 Muse - New Born +2
138 This Mortal Coil - You And Your Sister +8
121 Air - All I Need
118 The Veils - Under The Folding Branches +3
117 The Sound - I Give You Pain
110 The Beatles - Let It Be
100 Procol Harum - Grand Hotel +6
87 Can - Half Past One
75 Kate Bush - This Woman's Work +4
58 Chris Bell - You And Your Sister +7
56 The Breeders - Safari


Deadline: 17.00 uur

De Puntverdeling is ook verdwenen, de volgende mag die ook even terugplaatsen.

Dit lijkt me inderdaad de juiste verklaring al was "donkere 80's geluid" nog wat treffender geweest

Puntenverdeling: 8-7-6-4-3-2 (dit laten staan!)

Ronde 1 - Ladder 55: thelion deelt geen +4 uit; pm gestuurd

179 Sinéad O'Connor - Troy +4
117 Peter Gabriel & Kate Bush - Don't Give Up +8
115 Novastar - Wrong +7
113 Mercury Rev - The Dark Is Rising +3
102 Built To Spill - Traces
98 Tindersticks - Bathtime +6
94 Marlena Shaw - California Soul
77 Radical Face - Glory +2
73 Coldplay - Amsterdam
61 The Knife - We Share Our Mother's Health
47 Ben E. King - What Is Soul

--------------------------

Ronde 1 - Ladder 56:

160 Muse - New Born
138 This Mortal Coil - You And Your Sister
124 The Sound - I Give You Pain +7
121 Air - All I Need
120 The Veils - Under The Folding Branches +2
118 The Beatles - Let It Be +8
106 Procol Harum - Grand Hotel +6
87 Can - Half Past One
79 Kate Bush - This Woman's Work +4
59 The Breeders - Safari +3
58 Chris Bell - You And Your Sister

Deadline: 17.00 uur

Puntenverdeling: 8-7-6-4-3-2 (dit laten staan!)

Ronde 1 - Ladder 55: thelion deelt geen +4 uit; pm gestuurd

187 Sinéad O'Connor - Troy +8
119 Peter Gabriel & Kate Bush - Don't Give Up +2
115 Novastar - Wrong
113 Mercury Rev - The Dark Is Rising
106 Built To Spill - Traces +4
105 Tindersticks - Bathtime +7
100 Marlena Shaw - California Soul +6
80 Radical Face - Glory +3
73 Coldplay - Amsterdam
61 The Knife - We Share Our Mother's Health
47 Ben E. King - What Is Soul

--------------------------

Ronde 1 - Ladder 56: Matige ladder.

160 Muse - New Born
146 This Mortal Coil - You And Your Sister +8
125 Air - All I Need +4
124 The Sound - I Give You Pain
123 The Veils - Under The Folding Branches +3
118 The Beatles - Let It Be
106 Procol Harum - Grand Hotel
94 Can - Half Past One +7
85 Kate Bush - This Woman's Work +6
61 The Breeders - Safari +2
58 Chris Bell - You And Your Sister

Deadline: 17.00 uur

Puntenverdeling: 8-7-6-4-3-2 (dit laten staan!)

Ronde 1 - Ladder 55:

194 Sinéad O'Connor - Troy +7
121 Peter Gabriel & Kate Bush - Don't Give Up +2
121 Mercury Rev - The Dark Is Rising +8
118 Novastar - Wrong +3
109 Tindersticks - Bathtime +4
106 Built To Spill - Traces
100 Marlena Shaw - California Soul
80 Radical Face - Glory
79 Coldplay - Amsterdam +6
61 The Knife - We Share Our Mother's Health
47 Ben E. King - What Is Soul

--------------------------

Ronde 1 - Ladder 56:

163 Muse - New Born +3
154 This Mortal Coil - You And Your Sister +8
129 Air - All I Need +4
125 The Veils - Under The Folding Branches +2
124 The Sound - I Give You Pain
118 The Beatles - Let It Be
113 Procol Harum - Grand Hotel +7
94 Can - Half Past One
91 Kate Bush - This Woman's Work +6
61 The Breeders - Safari
58 Chris Bell - You And Your Sister

Deadline: 17.00 uur

Ik zit onwijs te kloten met knippen en plakken op m'n telefoon, maar het lukt niet . Kan iemand m'n punten meenemen?

8 Sinead O'Connor
7 The Knife
6 Marlena Shaw
4 Built to Spill
3 Tindersticks
2 Peter Gabriel

8 Chris Bell
7 This Mortal Coil
6 Kate Bush
4 Can
3 Air
2 The Breeders

Puntenverdeling: 8-7-6-4-3-2 (dit laten staan!)

Ronde 1 - Ladder 55:

210 Sinéad O'Connor - Troy +8 +8
130 Peter Gabriel & Kate Bush - Don't Give Up +2 +7
123 Mercury Rev - The Dark Is Rising +2
122 Novastar - Wrong +4
112 Tindersticks - Bathtime +3
110 Built To Spill - Traces +4
106 Marlena Shaw - California Soul +6
85 Coldplay - Amsterdam +6
80 Radical Face - Glory
68 The Knife - We Share Our Mother's Health +7
50 Ben E. King - What Is Soul +3

--------------------------

Ronde 1 - Ladder 56:

171 Muse - New Born +8
168 This Mortal Coil - You And Your Sister +7 +7
134 Air - All I Need +3 +2
125 The Veils - Under The Folding Branches
124 The Sound - I Give You Pain
124 The Beatles - Let It Be +6
116 Procol Harum - Grand Hotel +3
101 Kate Bush - This Woman's Work +6 +4
98 Can - Half Past One +4
63 The Breeders - Safari +2
66 Chris Bell - You And Your Sister +8

Deadline: 17.00 uur

Eerst genoemde punten ziijn van Dwejkk_

Puntenverdeling: 8-7-6-4-3-2 (dit laten staan!)

Ronde 1 - Ladder 55:

217 Sinéad O'Connor - Troy +7
136 Peter Gabriel & Kate Bush - Don't Give Up +6
126 Novastar - Wrong +4
123 Mercury Rev - The Dark Is Rising
114 Marlena Shaw - California Soul +8
113 Built To Spill - Traces +3
112 Tindersticks - Bathtime
85 Coldplay - Amsterdam
80 Radical Face - Glory
68 The Knife - We Share Our Mother's Health
52 Ben E. King - What Is Soul +2

--------------------------

Ronde 1 - Ladder 56:

172 This Mortal Coil - You And Your Sister +4
171 Muse - New Born
140 Air - All I Need +6
132 The Sound - I Give You Pain +8
125 The Veils - Under The Folding Branches
124 The Beatles - Let It Be
119 Procol Harum - Grand Hotel +3
101 Kate Bush - This Woman's Work
98 Can - Half Past One
73 Chris Bell - You And Your Sister +7
65 The Breeders - Safari +2

Deadline: 17.00 uur

Puntenverdeling: 8-7-6-4-3-2 (dit laten staan!)

Ronde 1 - Ladder 55: pas, al gestemd

217 Sinéad O'Connor - Troy
136 Peter Gabriel & Kate Bush - Don't Give Up
126 Novastar - Wrong
123 Mercury Rev - The Dark Is Rising
114 Marlena Shaw - California Soul
113 Built To Spill - Traces
112 Tindersticks - Bathtime
85 Coldplay - Amsterdam
80 Radical Face - Glory
68 The Knife - We Share Our Mother's Health
52 Ben E. King - What Is Soul

--------------------------

Ronde 1 - Ladder 56:

175 This Mortal Coil - You And Your Sister 3
171 Muse - New Born
144 Air - All I Need 4
134 The Sound - I Give You Pain 2
130 The Beatles - Let It Be 6
125 The Veils - Under The Folding Branches
119 Procol Harum - Grand Hotel
105 Can - Half Past One 7
101 Kate Bush - This Woman's Work
73 Chris Bell - You And Your Sister
73 The Breeders - Safari 8 (ontdekking!)

Deadline: 17.00 uur

Puntenverdeling: 8-7-6-4-3-2 (dit laten staan!)

Ronde 1 - Ladder 55:

217 Sinéad O'Connor - Troy
139 Peter Gabriel & Kate Bush - Don't Give Up +3
127 Mercury Rev - The Dark Is Rising +4
126 Novastar - Wrong
114 Marlena Shaw - California Soul
121 Built To Spill - Traces +8
118 Tindersticks - Bathtime +6
85 Coldplay - Amsterdam
82 Radical Face - Glory +2
75 The Knife - We Share Our Mother's Health +7
52 Ben E. King - What Is Soul

--------------------------

Ronde 1 - Ladder 56:

178 This Mortal Coil - You And Your Sister +3
173 Muse - New Born +2
144 Air - All I Need
140 The Sound - I Give You Pain +6
130 The Beatles - Let It Be
129 The Veils - Under The Folding Branches +4
119 Procol Harum - Grand Hotel
112 Can - Half Past One +7
101 Kate Bush - This Woman's Work
81 The Breeders - Safari +8
73 Chris Bell - You And Your Sister

Deadline: 17.00 uur

Puntenverdeling: 8-7-6-4-3-2 (dit laten staan!)

Ronde 1 - Ladder 55:

221 Sinéad O'Connor - Troy 4
141 Peter Gabriel & Kate Bush - Don't Give Up 2
133 Mercury Rev - The Dark Is Rising +6
126 Novastar - Wrong
114 Marlena Shaw - California Soul
121 Built To Spill - Traces
118 Tindersticks - Bathtime
93 Coldplay - Amsterdam 8
82 Radical Face - Glory
82 The Knife - We Share Our Mother's Health +7
55 Ben E. King - What Is Soul 3

--------------------------

Ronde 1 - Ladder 56:

181 This Mortal Coil - You And Your Sister +3
181 Muse - New Born +8
151 Air - All I Need 7
140 The Sound - I Give You Pain
132 The Beatles - Let It Be 2
135 The Veils - Under The Folding Branches +6
119 Procol Harum - Grand Hotel
112 Can - Half Past One
105 Kate Bush - This Woman's Work 4
81 The Breeders - Safari
73 Chris Bell - You And Your Sister

Deadline: 17.00 uur