Het is misschien wat chargerend om ze alle drie te noemen (twee ervan eindigden nu ook weer niet zo ver onder de puntengrens), maar over de kwaliteit van het veelgeroemde Speed Your Love to Me tast ik echt al in het duister sinds ik het nummer ken... met afstand het zwakste wat er bij die eerste 24 staat.

Het zijn ook niet mijn favorieten, maar zwakste vind ik niet (misschien wel gemakkelijker). Anyway, als ik het zo snel zie ben jij met Vigil(een beetje) die er iig niet (echt) op stemt , maar het is jouw mening

edit: het is wat wisselend zie ik nu betreffende SYLTM

Precies, laat mij maar even zeuren... jij hebt het gelijk van het scorebord al aan je kant.

Toch heb ik op zich Sparkle in the Rain nog redelijk hog zitten. East at Easter scoorde nog een paar punten en als "C"Moon Cry Like a Baby ertussen gestaan had, had die nog wat meer punten gescoord. Maar de beste nummers van de eerste vijf albums (met name de 2e t/m de 5e)... ja, dat is toch welhaast magie he.

Ik zelf geef overigens er ook niet de meeste punten aan die van SITR (3,4 en 5), enfin.

Geef 12-11-10-9-8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1

Simple Minds (1979 t/m 1984) vs. Simple Minds (1985 t/m 2009)

1979 t/m 1984

72 New Gold Dream (81-82-83-84) 3
70 Someone, Somewhere in Summertime +9
57 Theme for Great Cities +12
51 Big Sleep
49 Waterfront 1
46 I Travel +8
44 Up on the Catwalk
41 Seeing Out the Angel +7
33 Love Song +11
33 Hunter and the Hunted
27 The American 2
26 Speed Your Love to Me
22 Factory
21 Promised You a Miracle 5
19 In Trance as Mission 10
18 Premonition
17 20th Century Promised Land
17 East at Easter
14 Sweat in Bullet 6
11 Changeling
9 This Fear of Gods
5 Chelsea Girl 4
0 Celebrate
0 Life in a Day

1985 t/m 2009

69 Sanctify Yourself +10
63 All the Things She Said 9
57 Alive and Kicking 11
48 Don't You (Forget About Me) 12
46 See the Lights +7
40 Real Life +8
39 Belfast Child
35 Let There Be Love
31 This Is Your Land 6
28 Street Fighting Years
26 Oh Jungleland +5
24 Soul Crying Out
23 Stay Visible +3
17 Underneath the Ice 1
17 And the Band Played On +4
14 She's a River 2
12 Stars Will Lead the Way
11 Glitterball
9 Spaceface
7 Hypnotised
5 Moscow Underground
3 War Babies
0 Blood Type "O"
0 One Step Closer

Deadline vrijdag ca. 20.15

Speed doet mij ook niet zo veel, de andere twee vind ik al stukken beter. Waterfront valt net buiten de punten (maar ja de tegenstand is belachelijk sterk), dan zou ik overigens voor de City of Lights live versie gaan. Up on the Catwalk heeft wel punten gehaald. dit heb ik altijd al wel een sterk nummer gevonden, lekker nerveus liedje.

Deadline eindigt vanavond

Geef 12-11-10-9-8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1

Simple Minds (1979 t/m 1984) vs. Simple Minds (1985 t/m 2009)

1979 t/m 1984

83 New Gold Dream (81-82-83-84) +11
82 Someone, Somewhere in Summertime +12
59 Waterfront +10
63 Theme for Great Cities +5
54 I Travel +8
51 Big Sleep
47 Up on the Catwalk +3
45 Seeing Out the Angel +4
42 Hunter and the Hunted +9
35 Love Song +2
34 The American +7
27 Promised You a Miracle +6
26 Speed Your Love to Me
22 Factory
19 In Trance as Mission
18 Premonition
17 20th Century Promised Land
17 East at Easter
15 Sweat in Bullet +1
11 Changeling
9 This Fear of Gods
5 Chelsea Girl
0 Celebrate
0 Life in a Day

1985 t/m 2009

77 Sanctify Yourself +8
74 All the Things She Said +11
69 Alive and Kicking +12
57 Don't You (Forget About Me) +9
49 Belfast Child +10
48 See the Lights +2
43 Real Life +3
42 Let There Be Love +7
36 This Is Your Land +5
34 Street Fighting Years +6
30 Oh Jungleland +4
24 Soul Crying Out
24 Stay Visible +1
17 Underneath the Ice
17 And the Band Played On
14 She's a River
12 Stars Will Lead the Way
11 Glitterball
9 Spaceface
7 Hypnotised
5 Moscow Underground
3 War Babies
0 Blood Type "O"
0 One Step Closer

Deadline vrijdag ca. 20.15

Finale!

Zet je 12 favoriete Simple Minds nummers op een rij.

Geef 12-11-10-9-8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1 punt

0 New Gold Dream (81-82-83-84)
0 Someone, Somewhere in Summertime
0 Waterfront
0 Theme for Great Cities
0 I Travel
0 Big Sleep
0 Up on the Catwalk
0 Seeing Out the Angel
0 Hunter and the Hunted
0 Love Song
0 The American
0 Promised You a Miracle
0 Sanctify Yourself
0 All the Things She Said
0 Alive and Kicking
0 Don't You (Forget About Me)
0 Belfast Child
0 See the Lights
0 Real Life
0 Let There Be Love
0 This Is Your Land
0 Street Fighting Years
0 Oh Jungleland
0 Soul Crying Out

Deadline woensdag ca. 20.00

Finale!

Zet je 12 favoriete Simple Minds nummers op een rij.

Geef 12-11-10-9-8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1 punt

12 New Gold Dream (81-82-83-84)
11 Someone, Somewhere in Summertime
10 Big Sleep
9 I Travel
8 Waterfront
7 Love Song
6 Hunter and the Hunted
5 The American
4 Up on the Catwalk
3 Promised You a Miracle
2 Sanctify Yourself
1 All the Things She Said
0 Theme for Great Cities
0 Seeing Out the Angel
0 Alive and Kicking
0 Don't You (Forget About Me)
0 Belfast Child
0 See the Lights
0 Real Life
0 Let There Be Love
0 This Is Your Land
0 Street Fighting Years
0 Oh Jungleland
0 Soul Crying Out

Deadline woensdag ca. 20.00

Liefhebber van het oude werk!
"C" Moon Cry Like a Baby had zeker de top 5 gehaald.

Hé, nu kan ik wel stemmen.

Finale!

Zet je 12 favoriete Simple Minds nummers op een rij.

Geef 12-11-10-9-8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1 punt

22 Someone, Somewhere in Summertime +11
16 Hunter and the Hunted +10
16 Waterfront +8
16 Big Sleep +6
14 New Gold Dream (81-82-83-84) +2
12 Theme for Great Cities +12
9 Don't You (Forget About Me) +9
9 I Travel
7 Alive and Kicking +7
7 Promised You a Miracle +4
7 Love Song
5 Belfast Child +5
5 The American
4 Up on the Catwalk
3 Oh Jungleland +3
3 Sanctify Yourself +1
1 All the Things She Said
0 Seeing Out the Angel
0 See the Lights
0 Real Life
0 Let There Be Love
0 This Is Your Land
0 Street Fighting Years
0 Soul Crying Out

Deadline woensdag ca. 20.00

Finale!

Zet je 12 favoriete Simple Minds nummers op een rij.

Geef 12-11-10-9-8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1 punt

25 Waterfront +9
25 Someone, Somewhere in Summertime +3
21 Don't You (Forget About Me) +12
20 Theme for Great Cities +8
16 Hunter and the Hunted
16 Big Sleep
15 The American +10
14 Sanctify Yourself +11
14 Promised You a Miracle +7
14 New Gold Dream (81-82-83-84)
12 Alive and Kicking +5
9 I Travel
7 Belfast Child +2
7 Love Song
6 Let There Be Love +6
5 All the Things She Said +4
4 Up on the Catwalk
3 Oh Jungleland
1 Soul Crying Out +1
0 Seeing Out the Angel
0 See the Lights
0 Real Life
0 This Is Your Land
0 Street Fighting Years

Deadline woensdag ca. 20.00

Stars Will Lead the Way, Stay Visible, Underneath the Ice

Zet je 12 favoriete Simple Minds nummers op een rij.

Geef 12-11-10-9-8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1 punt

30 Theme for Great Cities 10
27 Someone, Somewhere in Summertime 2
25 Big Sleep 9
25 New Gold Dream (81-82-83-84) 11
25 Waterfront
21 I Travel 12
21 Don't You (Forget About Me)
21 Hunter and the Hunted 5
18 The American 3
14 Sanctify Yourself
14 Promised You a Miracle
12 Up on the Catwalk 8
12 Alive and Kicking
7 Belfast Child
7 Real Life 7
7 Love Song
6 Street Fighting Years 6
6 Let There Be Love
5 All the Things She Said
3 Oh Jungleland
1 Soul Crying Out
0 Seeing Out the Angel
0 See the Lights
4 This Is Your Land 4

Deadline woensdag ca. 20.00

Zet je 12 favoriete Simple Minds nummers op een rij.

Geef 12-11-10-9-8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1 punt

39 Someone, Somewhere in Summertime +12
36 New Gold Dream (81-82-83-84) +11
35 Waterfront +10
31 Theme for Great Cities +1
29 Hunter and the Hunted +8
27 I Travel +6
25 Big Sleep
25 Don't You (Forget About Me) +4
21 Alive and Kicking +9
21 The American +3
16 Promised You a Miracle +2
14 Sanctify Yourself
12 Up on the Catwalk
12 All the Things She Said +7
12 Belfast Child +5
7 Real Life
7 Love Song
6 Street Fighting Years
6 Let There Be Love
4 This Is Your Land
3 Oh Jungleland
1 Soul Crying Out
0 Seeing Out the Angel
0 See the Lights

Deadline woensdag ca. 20.00

Zet je 12 favoriete Simple Minds nummers op een rij.

Geef 12-11-10-9-8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1 punt

49 Someone, Somewhere in Summertime +10
47 New Gold Dream (81-82-83-84) +11
40 Waterfront +5
40 Theme for Great Cities +9
33 Big Sleep +8
29 Hunter and the Hunted
28 Alive and Kicking +7
27 The American +6
27 I Travel
26 Don't You (Forget About Me) +1
16 Promised You a Miracle
16 Up on the Catwalk +4
15 All the Things She Said +3
14 Sanctify Yourself
14 Belfast Child +2
12 Seeing Out the Angel +12
7 Real Life
7 Love Song
6 Street Fighting Years
6 Let There Be Love
4 This Is Your Land
3 Oh Jungleland
1 Soul Crying Out
0 See the Lights

Deadline woensdag ca. 20.00

Aangezien er genoeg Simple Minds volgers zijn op MuMe hoop ik toch op nog wel wat meer lijstjes.

Zet je 12 favoriete Simple Minds nummers op een rij.

Geef 12-11-10-9-8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1 punt

60 Someone, Somewhere in Summertime +11
59 New Gold Dream (81-82-83-84) +12
47 Theme for Great Cities +7
46 Waterfront +6
35 I Travel +8
33 Big Sleep
32 Hunter and the Hunted +3
32 The American +5
30 Alive and Kicking +2
26 Don't You (Forget About Me)
25 Up on the Catwalk +9
17 Love Song +10
17 Promised You a Miracle +1
16 Seeing Out the Angel +4
15 All the Things She Said
14 Sanctify Yourself
14 Belfast Child
7 Real Life
6 Street Fighting Years
6 Let There Be Love
4 This Is Your Land
3 Oh Jungleland
1 Soul Crying Out
0 See the Lights

Deadline woensdag ca. 20.00

Zet je 12 favoriete Simple Minds nummers op een rij.

Geef 12-11-10-9-8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1 punt

71 New Gold Dream (81-82-83-84) 12
70 Someone, Somewhere in Summertime 10
55 Waterfront 9
54 Theme for Great Cities 7
41 Alive and Kicking 11
38 I Travel 3
33 Big Sleep
32 Hunter and the Hunted
32 The American
31 Don't You (Forget About Me) 5
26 Up on the Catwalk 1
25 Promised You a Miracle 8
20 Belfast Child 6
17 Love Song
16 Sanctify Yourself 2
16 Seeing Out the Angel
15 All the Things She Said
10 Let There Be Love 4
7 Real Life
6 Street Fighting Years
4 This Is Your Land
3 Oh Jungleland
1 Soul Crying Out
0 See the Lights

Deadline woensdag ca. 20.00

Zet je 12 favoriete Simple Minds nummers op een rij.

Geef 12-11-10-9-8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1 punt

80 Someone, Somewhere in Summertime +10
72 New Gold Dream (81-82-83-84) +1
61 Theme for Great Cities +7
55 Waterfront
47 I Travel +9
45 Big Sleep +12
41 Alive and Kicking
32 Hunter and the Hunted
32 The American
31 Don't You (Forget About Me)
27 Seeing Out the Angel +11
26 Up on the Catwalk
25 Promised You a Miracle
22 Belfast Child +2
21 Love Song +4
16 Sanctify Yourself
15 All the Things She Said
14 Street Fighting Years +8
13 Real Life +6
10 Let There Be Love
8 Oh Jungleland +5
4 This Is Your Land
3 See the Lights +3
1 Soul Crying Out

Deadline woensdag ca. 20.00

Zet je 12 favoriete Simple Minds nummers op een rij.

Geef 12-11-10-9-8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1 punt

85 Someone, Somewhere in Summertime +5
83 New Gold Dream (81-82-83-84) +11
69 Theme for Great Cities +8
57 Waterfront +2
55 Big Sleep +10
48 I Travel +1
44 Hunter and the Hunted +12
41 Alive and Kicking
37 The American +5
36 Seeing Out the Angel +9
35 Don't You (Forget About Me) +4
33 Up on the Catwalk +7
28 Promised You a Miracle +3
27 Love Song +6
22 Belfast Child
16 Sanctify Yourself
15 All the Things She Said
14 Street Fighting Years
13 Real Life
10 Let There Be Love
8 Oh Jungleland
4 This Is Your Land
3 See the Lights
1 Soul Crying Out

Deadline woensdag ca. 20.00

Waar zijn de prachtsongs This Earth That You Walk Upon en League Of Nations ...

Daarvoor kun je je beklag doen bij vigil

Zet je 12 favoriete Simple Minds nummers op een rij.

Geef 12-11-10-9-8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1 punt

94 New Gold Dream (81-82-83-84) 11
91 Someone, Somewhere in Summertime 6
69 Theme for Great Cities
69 Waterfront 12
64 Big Sleep 9
49 Hunter and the Hunted 5
48 I Travel
48 Alive and Kicking 7
43 Up on the Catwalk 10
37 Don't You (Forget About Me) 2
37 The American
36 Seeing Out the Angel
29 Promised You a Miracle 1
27 Love Song
24 Sanctify Yourself 8
22 Belfast Child
18 All the Things She Said 3
14 Street Fighting Years
13 Real Life
10 Let There Be Love
8 Oh Jungleland
8 This Is Your Land 4
3 See the Lights
1 Soul Crying Out

Deadline woensdag ca. 20.00

Zet je 12 favoriete Simple Minds nummers op een rij.

Geef 12-11-10-9-8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1 punt

98 New Gold Dream (81-82-83-84) 4
96 Someone, Somewhere in Summertime 5
81 Theme for Great Cities 12
70 Waterfront 1
64 Big Sleep
58 I Travel 10
55 Alive and Kicking 7
49 Hunter and the Hunted
46 The American 9
43 Up on the Catwalk
43 Don't You (Forget About Me) 6
39 Seeing Out the Angel 3
38 Love Song 11
37 Promised You a Miracle 8
24 Sanctify Yourself
22 Belfast Child
20 All the Things She Said 2
14 Street Fighting Years
13 Real Life
10 Let There Be Love
8 Oh Jungleland
8 This Is Your Land
3 See the Lights
1 Soul Crying Out

Deadline woensdag ca. 20.00

Zet je 12 favoriete Simple Minds nummers op een rij.

Geef 12-11-10-9-8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1 punt

108 New Gold Dream (81-82-83-84) +10
108 Someone, Somewhere in Summertime +12
81 Theme for Great Cities
78 Waterfront +8
64 Big Sleep
59 Alive and Kicking +4
58 I Travel
55 Hunter and the Hunted +6
51 The American +5
50 Up on the Catwalk +7
43 Don't You (Forget About Me)
39 Seeing Out the Angel
39 Love Song +1
37 Promised You a Miracle
33 Belfast Child +11
26 Sanctify Yourself +2
23 All the Things She Said +3
14 Street Fighting Years
13 Real Life
12 See the Lights +9
10 Let There Be Love
8 Oh Jungleland
8 This Is Your Land
1 Soul Crying Out

Deadline woensdag ca. 20.00

Kijk gewoon even naar statistieken bij de betreffende albums en dan behoren deze nummers niet tot de favorieten van de kenners van dit album (This Earth zelfs pas zesde) . Dus dan doen ze helaas niet mee met de beste/bekendste 24.

Vandaag tot een uur of 20.00 kan je nog stemmen

De volgende is Genesis. Ik kan begrijpen dat je de ene periode beter kent dan de andere dus je mag gerust de ene periode wel en de andere geen punten geven.

Geef 12-11-10-9-8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1

Genesis tot 1977

Afterglow
Blood on the Rooftops
Can-Utility and the Coastliners
Carpet Crawlers
Colony of Slippermen
Dance on a Volcano
Dancing with the Moonlit Knight
Entangled
Firth of Fifth
In the Cage
One for the Vine
Ripples...
Stagnation
Supper's Ready
The Battle of Epping Forest
The Cinema Show
The Fountain of Salmacis
The Knife
The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway
The Lamia
The Musical Box
The Return of the Giant Hogweed
Visions of Angels
Watcher of the Skies

Genesis vanaf 1977

Abacab
Behind the Lines
Burning Rope
Calling All Stations
Dodo / Lurker
Domino
Driving the Last Spike
Duchess
Duke's Travels
Fading Lights
Follow You Follow Me
Home by the Sea
I Can't Dance
Invisible Touch
Jesus He Knows Me
Land of Confusion
Mama
No Son of Mine
Second Home by the Sea
That's All
The Dividing Line
Tonight, Tonight, Tonight
Turn It on Again
Undertow

deadline zondag uur of 20.30

Kwaliteitsverschil tussen beide periodes is ongeveer even evident als bij de vorige band.

Geef 12-11-10-9-8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1

Genesis tot 1977

12 The Fountain of Salmacis
11 The Musical Box
10 Entangled
9 Dancing with the Moonlit Knight
8 One for the Vine
7 Firth of Fifth
6 Ripples...
5 Carpet Crawlers
4 Can-Utility and the Coastliners
3 Supper's Ready
2 The Cinema Show
1 In the Cage
Afterglow
Blood on the Rooftops
Colony of Slippermen
Dance on a Volcano
Stagnation
The Battle of Epping Forest
The Knife
The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway
The Lamia
The Return of the Giant Hogweed
Visions of Angels
Watcher of the Skies

Genesis vanaf 1977

12 Driving the Last Spike
11 Burning Rope
10 Home by the Sea
9 The Dividing Line
8 Undertow
7 Calling All Stations
6 Behind the Lines
5 Land of Confusion
4 Dodo / Lurker
3 Abacab
2 Mama
1 Tonight, Tonight, Tonight
Domino
Duchess
Duke's Travels
Fading Lights
Follow You Follow Me
I Can't Dance
Invisible Touch
Jesus He Knows Me
No Son of Mine
Second Home by the Sea
That's All
Turn It on Again

deadline zondag uur of 20.30

hhhmmm, ik had toch blijkbaar meer nummers van Abacab moeten selecteren

Geef 12-11-10-9-8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1

Genesis tot 1977 Pas...en graag zelfs

12 The Fountain of Salmacis
11 The Musical Box
10 Entangled
9 Dancing with the Moonlit Knight
8 One for the Vine
7 Firth of Fifth
6 Ripples...
5 Carpet Crawlers
4 Can-Utility and the Coastliners
3 Supper's Ready
2 The Cinema Show
1 In the Cage
Afterglow
Blood on the Rooftops
Colony of Slippermen
Dance on a Volcano
Stagnation
The Battle of Epping Forest
The Knife
The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway
The Lamia
The Return of the Giant Hogweed
Visions of Angels
Watcher of the Skies

Genesis vanaf 1977

22 Home by the Sea +12
21 Driving the Last Spike +9
16 Land of Confusion +11
12 Mama +10
11 Burning Rope
9 The Dividing Line
8 That's All +8
8 Undertow
7 Second Home by the Sea +7
7 Calling All Stations
6 Domino +6
6 Behind the Lines
5 No Son of Mine +5
4 I Can't Dance +4
4 Dodo / Lurker
3 Invisible Touch +3
3 Abacab
2 Jesus He Knows Me +2
1 Follow You Follow Me +1
1 Tonight, Tonight, Tonight
Duchess
Duke's Travels
Fading Lights
Turn It on Again

deadline zondag uur of 20.30


We zijn het roerend met elkaar eens